Medium
Photo © Rob Curtis, some rights reserved
Mogadore Reservoir, OH (Google, OSM)
41.0604213, -81.3550663
Accuracy: 2718m
open
Jul. 14, 2012 15:41:27 -0400
Logo-eee-15px

Comments & Identifications

3161-thumb

Not a pumpkinseed ( Leponis gibbosus)?

Posted by greenrosettas almost 2 years ago (Flag)
4860-thumb

That was my first guess, but I am not a fish guy so I was leaning on others comments. I will pull my ID and let some others comment. Please make your vote count if you feel that is what it is.

Posted by rcurtis almost 2 years ago (Flag)
3161-thumb

Well honestly it is hard to say I lean towards pumpkinseed on it's coloration, but to key them out you need to look at their fins.

http://bio.slu.edu/mayden/sunfish/sun_key/1.html

Posted by greenrosettas almost 2 years ago (Flag)
4860-thumb

Oops

Posted by rcurtis almost 2 years ago (Flag)
4860-thumb
Lepomis - Photo (c) Cliff, some rights reserved (CC BY)
rcurtis's ID: Genus Lepomis, a member of Sunfishes (Family Centrarchidae)
Posted by rcurtis almost 2 years ago (Flag)
7474-thumb

The vertical bars are pretty prominent and I'm not seeing much in the way of blue lines across the cheek that would be typical of Lepomis gibbosus. I'm also not seeing any indication of an orange spot on the opercular flap, although this can sometimes be slight. They do also hybridize pretty readily. It looks more like a nicely colored adult Bluegill to me, albeit I can see some characteristics of a pumpkinseed.

Posted by sagamoreoh almost 2 years ago (Flag)
7474-thumb
Lepomis - Photo (c) Cliff, some rights reserved (CC BY)
sagamoreoh's ID: Genus Lepomis, a member of Sunfishes (Family Centrarchidae)
Posted by sagamoreoh almost 2 years ago (Flag)
7474-thumb

I passed the photo on to a fisheries colleague who agrees there seems to be clear indication of pumpkinseed in it despite the seeming lack of an opercular spot. Without having the fish in hand, the best guess is hybrid or weakly colored pumpkinseed. Good catch, greenrosettas.

Posted by sagamoreoh almost 2 years ago (Flag)
4860-thumb

Thanks for all the discussion. I definitely learned something.

Posted by rcurtis almost 2 years ago (Flag)
3161-thumb

Good stuff, you know I actually miss catching these fish. I used to be annoyed to no end when I reeled in these little guys because they would be stealing my bait. Since moving to California from Maine, I never get out and fish anymore. I really ought to invest in a pole again and dip my line.

Posted by greenrosettas almost 2 years ago (Flag)
30344-thumb
Lepomis - Photo (c) Cliff, some rights reserved (CC BY)
blanchardjesse's ID: Genus Lepomis, a member of Sunfishes (Family Centrarchidae)
Posted by blanchardjesse 15 days ago (Flag)
30344-thumb

I lean toward Lepomis megalotis, the longear sunfish. It lacks the pumpkinseed markings I'd look for and the earspot is englongated which rules out many other Lepomis spp. That said, I'd have to check the gill rakers and meristic counts to be certain. Or have a less blurry picture.

Posted by blanchardjesse 15 days ago (Flag)
Sign in or Sign up to add comments
Sign in or Sign up to add identifications

Identification Summary

Lepomis - Photo (c) Cliff, some rights reserved (CC BY)
rcurtis's ID: Genus Lepomis, a member of Sunfishes (Family Centrarchidae)
Lepomis - Photo (c) Cliff, some rights reserved (CC BY)
Community ID: Genus Lepomis, a member of Sunfishes (Family Centrarchidae)
About
sagamoreoh blanchardjesse 2 people agree
rcurtis would like some help identifying this

Suggest an ID

Sign in or Sign up to add IDs
Logo-eee-15px
Logo-eee-15px
Logo-eee-15px

Data Quality Assessment

Community-supported ID? Yes
2 people agree
0 people disagree
Date? Yes
Georeferenced? Yes
Photos or sounds? Yes
Is the organism wild/naturalized? Unknown
What do you think?
Yes / No
Does the location seem accurate? Unknown
What do you think?
Yes / No
Does the date seem accurate? Unknown
What do you think?
Yes / No
Quality grade research
Details Hide Details
Logo-eee-15px
Observation © Rob Curtis
Cc-by_small some rights reserved

Is this observation inappropriate, spam, or offensive? Flag this observation

If you think this observation is inaccurate, please add an ID, participate in the quality assessment above, or describe the inaccuracy in a comment.

Logo-eee-15px