Photographing Bush-mallows for Identification

A couple of the tricky things about bush-mallows is that the flowers all look pretty much identical from a strait-on view and the leaves can be really variable. This doesn't mean a photograph of them isn't useful, but I'm going to show you what will help most.

Most important, take a close-up side-view image of the flower. The calyx, bracts, and hairs are very important for ID. If the flowers aren't open, the buds can still be very useful. Here's a good example of Nuttall's bush-mallow (Malacothamnus fasciculatus var. nuttallii) showing the side view of a flower and bud:

If the inflorescence is really dense, you can pull off an individual flower and just photograph that from the side. If you do this, try to get the three bracts just below the calyx. The length and shape of these compared to the calyx is very important. Here's and example of a many-flowered bush-mallow (Malacothamnus densiflorus) where I plucked off a flower for a better photo:

It's also good to have a photo of the whole inflorescence. Here's again Nuttall's bush-mallow:

Stem hairs are extremely important. Hairs can vary along the stem based on the maturity of that area. If I only photograph one spot, I usually focus near the base of the inflorescence as that area is more consistent than the various maturities near the tip. Note in this photo how you can easily see the individual stem hairs on the left and not so much on the right:

Glandular hairs are often very difficult to see and photograph, but are very important for differentiating some species/taxa. Note the thicker-based, yellow-green hairs in this photo of Arroyo Seco bush-mallow (Malacothamnus palmeri var. lucianus):

While they may not get you to the species by itself, leaves can certainly help. Color, hairs, shape, and difference between top and bottom can be helpful. Higher/immature leaves may look quite different from lower/mature leaves. Note in this photo of horehound bush-mallow (Malacothamnus marrubioides) I show both sides of the leaves:

Recently I found that the way the flowers dry may be important for identification. Note in this photo of Heller's bush-mallow (Malacothamnus helleri) how the flowers are drying fairly open:

In this photo of arcuate bush-mallow (Malacothamnus arcuatus), you can see how the flowers are drying closed:

If you are in a desert transition area and all you have is fruit, take a photo of the carpels which will distinguish Malacothamnus from Sphaeralcea:

The more photos you take of different parts of the plant, the easier it is to identify. Good luck!

Posted on September 9, 2016 07:38 PM by keirmorse keirmorse

Comments

Great examples, and something that I wasn't aware of.

Posted by finatic over 7 years ago

Will definitely try and keep these tips in mind the next time I see one.

Posted by kueda over 7 years ago

Me too!

Posted by leslie_flint over 7 years ago

nice thanks for the tips

Posted by loarie about 7 years ago

Thanks!

Posted by hfabian about 7 years ago

I just updated this post to include a few more examples and add drying flowers which might turn out to be very useful for some species.

Posted by keirmorse almost 7 years ago

awesome, thanks! I'll apply these to others plants as well that give me headaches, like the Plagiobothrys haha.

Posted by myosotisalpestris over 6 years ago

Interesting! I'll refer to this next time I'm out and about.

Posted by hogpotato over 6 years ago

Excellent tips! Thank you.

Posted by fieryskipper about 6 years ago

Thanks so very much---very useful!

Posted by desertnaturalist almost 6 years ago

You're welocme

Posted by hfabian almost 6 years ago

Thank you, this is super information on how to photograph bush-mallows and other plants.

Posted by bryn_potter over 5 years ago

great stuff!

Posted by eightysixcrooks over 4 years ago

Carpels added with examples of Malacothamnus vs. Sphaeralcea.

Posted by keirmorse over 4 years ago

great info! Will keep these in mind when photographing.

Posted by sshigenaga almost 2 years ago

I am just now seeing this and will try to remember these tips when I'm in the field

Posted by elizabeth_lockhart almost 2 years ago

Excellent, thanks for the tips!

Posted by jessicahadden over 1 year ago

Thanks for the great details and photos

Posted by allisoncj 10 months ago

Thank you very much for this very informative tutorial. Great tips that I will use out in the field

Posted by ebhiker 7 months ago

Finally something that helps me distinguish these plants.
Please post more ways to identify. I am in Santa Clarita, We had a fire 4 years ago.. these guys are everywhere. I think that in my small area there are at least 5 species

Posted by rudester 6 months ago

@rudester The Santa Clarita area is pretty messy with plants intermediate between species. That said, most are pretty distinct outside the areas of intermediates. Check out the new treatment, which has a key, photos, and maps. Also, check out what the Malacothamnus are IDd to on iNat in the area you are. I don't know how long I'll keep IDing them but I've IDd a huge amount of them in the past.

Treatment here:
https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.23937066

Posted by keirmorse 6 months ago

Thanks!

Posted by hfabian 6 months ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments