iNat Photos Used to Study Correlation Between Dragonfly Wing Coloration and Temperature

I came across this article in January and thought the study was a great example of how iNaturalist data can be used for research, so I reached out to researcher Michael Moore (@moore-evo-eco) about it. He was gracious enough to spend some of his time to answer my questions. Thank you Michael!


Michael Moore, a graduate biology student at Case Western Reserve University in Ohio, says he’s been studying blue dasher dragonflies for his research over the course of a few years, pretty much because they’re common across much of the middle of North America. Before he had even done field research with this species, Michael heard that males in the eastern part of the continent had darker wings than those on the western side. “I kind of filed that anecdote away in the back of my brain while I used the species for research in other topics,” he recalls. “But in the winter of 2016-2017, while I waited for the snow to clear so I could get back out there and do some research, I realized that the reason this dragonfly species has different wing color patterns in different parts of North America might be really interesting and worth investigating.”

Blue dashers would not be flying until the weather warmed, but Michael was chomping at the bit to get started with his research so he turned to iNat. “When I went to check the iNaturalist page for blue dashers, I could not believe how many really, really high-quality pictures there were just of this one species I happen to research,” he tells me. “I think at this point there are like 13,500 observations--so trove is definitely the right word...

Once I started looking through these pictures, I realized that the information that iNaturalist stores was literally everything I needed not just to get some preliminary data, but to decisively address where the dragonfly tended to get the color on its wings and where it did not....After seeing that pattern from the iNaturalist photos, there was no question that I was on to something. I applied for a bunch of small grants for experiments on how I would follow up on this exciting geographic pattern, and I got enough funding from the American Museum of Natural History and my department that I could do the experiments. Without the amazing collection of pictures of just this one little dragonfly on iNaturalist, I'm not sure any of the rest of this research would have been possible.

After getting range and wing coloration data from iNaturalist, Michael and his colleagues obtained male specimens and tested how wing coloration affected the dragonflies’ body temperatures; whether or not a higher body temperature translated into better flight performance; how wing coloration and weather affected a male’s ability to defend territory; and finally, whether wing coloration was reduced in hotter parts of the species’ range (using iNaturalist observations). What they found was that increased body temperature did improve flight performance - up to a point. Once the dragonfly’s body temperature was too high, flight performance was negatively impacted, thus reducing the male’s ability to defend territory and in turn mate with a female. So the reduced wing coloration in hotter areas of the blue dasher’s range does correlate with sexual selection and fitness.

“For me at least, the first big benefit of the data available from iNaturalist is the sheer volume of high-quality observations that are available for some species. It's still hard for me to get my head around,” says Michael. “While gathering natural-history observations is a key element of biological research, it would take years for a small team of researchers to collect that many observations. This can really jumpstart the process of identifying patterns and figuring out which ones are worth designing experiments to understand at a deeper level.” He does acknowledge that he lucked out with blue dashers because they are a charismatic, commonly observed species, and he also wishes that the photos were more standardized, so he says “I suspect that plants and animals that don't catch people's eye quite as much might not be as amenable to these kinds of studies. But these are small drawbacks when compared to the really amazing opportunities that platforms like iNaturalist present...

as more and more researchers start working with these great platforms, I really think we could witness an explosion of newly uncovered patterns in global biodiversity. The key then will obviously be to design careful follow-up experiments to help us understand why these patterns arise in the first place, but the possibilities that iNaturalist and eBird present as a jumping off point are remarkable…

...Because we are now accumulating this remarkable collection of time-stamped photographs of every manner of plant, animal, and fungi through iNaturalist and similar platforms, we're potentially going to have a digitized record of how each of these organisms evolve over the next few decades. We'll be able to watch evolution occurring on a grand scale. From a purely academic perspective, it's every evolutionary biologists dream.

What’s next for Michael? He has some ideas about how iNaturalist and other crowdsourced data can be used, but he’s also interested in following up on this dragonfly study. “Like many research projects, there are a lot more questions that this study raises than answers,” he says. “Did the dragonflies evolve to have reduced wing coloration in the hotter areas, or vice versa? What about areas where they don’t have much wing coloration yet the temperatures are not as hot?

“Identifying the evolutionary forces that act in addition to temperature to cause these patterns will hopefully help biologists understand how animals adapt to simultaneously balance the competing demands of multiple environmental factors,” Michael concludes. “Without that initial boost from the iNaturalist dataset, I probably never would have looked seriously at the role of temperature in the evolution of this trait, and we would have had no idea that we could use this species to examine these all of these important evolutionary ideas and concepts”

By Tony Iwane

Photos: Male blue dasher in Ohio by Dave McShaffrey (top); Male blue dasher in Arizona by Alex Lamoreaux (middle).


- This study is under embargo for a year, but an abstract can be found here. Michael’s co-authors were Cassandra Lis, Iulian Gherghel, and Ryan A. Martin.

Check out another ongoing study that’s using iNat photos of mountain goats.

- A blue dasher photo was chosen as an iNat Observation of the Day. However, its in the jaws of a snake! Great photos. 

Posted by tiwane tiwane, February 28, 2019 08:44 PM

Comments

Thumb

It's all so wonderful and interesting! Thank you all for these gifts.

Posted by alessandradalia 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

That's really cool! It encourages me to post even more observations!

Posted by tuftedparidae 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

@tuftedparidae , that, and it makes me to want to annotate observations (mine and others). Imagine how much easier it is for researchers to data mine when they can filter on what they're looking for (like adult life stage and male sex in this case).

Posted by star3 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

That's awesome! Thanks for sharing this with us!
The list of the observations that were used (with their GPS coordinates, and County of observation) for the study is available here https://datadryad.org/resource/doi:10.5061/dryad.g9v97vq in the table "Moore_et_al_ELE_geo_var.csv". From there, it's not to hard to find out if one of your observations contributed to the study...

Posted by tkoffel 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

Fantastic work!

Posted by erikamitchell 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

Super cool!

Posted by sea-kangaroo 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

Yay! it is true that we will soon see more and more of iNat's observations turned into research papers. And yes annotations are important for all the extra data they carry.

Posted by susanhewitt 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

Bear in mind that Blue Dashers have little wing color throughout much of the West, where the temperatures range from very hot (Arizona) to downright cool (Seattle, where I live). They are colored the same in eastern (hot) and western (cool) Washington. So it's not a clearcut response to temperature. Nonetheless, it's a wonderful attempt to use a citizen-science platform for actual research.
Dennis Paulson, Seattle, WA

Posted by dennispaulson 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

It's heartening to hear about this study using iNaturalist data. I hope iNaturalist users will be given word of and access to some of the results of this and future studies using their data.

Posted by edwardrooks 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

Thanks Tony for this great article!

Posted by mikef451 19 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

This is exciting! What a wonderful and interesting article. Thank you for taking the time to share this with all of us on iNaturalsit.

Posted by walkingstick2 18 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

Really exciting read. Thank you all...

Posted by robberfly 18 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

Great stuff! Michael will be speaking at the Ohio Dragonfly Conference in May. Great chance for people to see how their data is being used. Good photo at the top of the article, too! :)

Posted by dmcshaffrey 17 days ago (Flag)
Thumb

Great stuff, and happy to have an infinitesimal part of it. I'll expect my commission any day now. Maybe a fragment of an AMNH coffee mug ;-).

Posted by boruma 12 days ago (Flag)

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments

Is this inappropriate, spam, or offensive? Add a Flag