Flagger Content Author Content Reason Flag Created Resolved by Resolution
nicklambert Man O' Wars (Genus Physalia)

I want to add the species Physalia utriculus. Is there a reason it is not separated? See this observation for links https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/19508476#activity_comment_2432021

Jan. 8, 2019 12:08:56 +0000 tonyrebelo

discussed

Comments

we follow worms:
http://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=135382

utriculosus is regarded as a synonym of physalis
http://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=387269

All the articles separating the two are quite old.

I dont know the reasons for lumping them ...

Posted by tonyrebelo over 5 years ago

This is both a yes-and-no situation that doesn't have a good solution. Taxonomy for the genus Physalia is generally a nightmare, and nothing's really accurate. Very old sources separated P. physalis and P. utriculosus. Old but less-old sources combined the genus into a single species, frankly as lazy taxonomy. Less obsolete sources suggest there is definitive evidence of more than one species. However, the actual research necessary to separate and describe these species remains incomplete. So… even if P. utriculosus should be considered to be valid, there isn't enough research into whether it would be defined in the sense of those very old sources, if it would be more broadly defined, or if it would be more narrowly defined. This is more generally summarized in the other Jon's comment here.

It's not an optimum situation by any means, as a future taxonomic split may or may not separate well by geography and thus may require a ton of re-identifying. While there may be reason to propose an explicit deviation from WoRMS, I just don't think the literature is to the point that it would be a stable separation.

See other flags:
• https://www.inaturalist.org/flags/212597
• https://www.inaturalist.org/flags/211352

Posted by jonathan142 over 5 years ago

Thanks - most useful.

Nick - is this adequate? Can we resolve it?

Posted by tonyrebelo over 5 years ago

@tonyrebelo @jonathan142 Thanks for the explanation guys.

Posted by nicklambert over 5 years ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments