Flagger | Content Author | Content | Reason | Flag Created | Resolved by | Resolution |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
sariai | Tricholoma myomyces |
Search for Tricholoma terreum gives two suggestions: Tricholoma terreum and Tricholoma myomyces. |
Nov. 17, 2020 19:57:40 +0000 | nschwab |
Swapped into Tricholoma terreum while keeping var. |
@jameskm could you do the split please. I'm not confident with atlasing.
No. You need to do it manually first.
If you tick 'move children to output' then as far as I recall it would automatically create the invalid Tricholoma terreum var. cystidotum. We should not be inventing and propagating invalid names in iNat. The current design inappropriately assumes ICZN rules. I have had this discussion in the past and staff need to wake up to the fact that ICN is not the same as ICZN and the current design provides no other option. Better taxonomic/nomenclatural design (and the observation identification design) would allow that, but we stuck with current system. Please do not invent invalid combinations.
@cooperj I have already done that multiple times when revising Entoloma and it didn't work that way. Maybe something changed under the hood?
There are differing opinions on whether T. myomyces is a good species or a synonym of T. terreum. In my opinion they are synonyms (following Fungi Northern Europe volume 4). Current sequence data suggests the use of the name T. myomyces in North America is usually a misapplication of T. triste or T. bonii but there isn't much on this in the literarture.
So, I would support synonymisation but I'm not sure much can be done with North American misapplications