Flagger Content Author Content Reason Flag Created Resolved by Resolution
louisb Common Swallowtails (Genus Papilio)

Big changes proposed by Condamine et al 2023

Mar. 12, 2023 21:53:51 +0000 Not Resolved

Comments

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ympev.2023.107758

Possibly close to 100 changes needed - will add in comments.

Posted by louisb about 1 year ago

"We had trouble saving that comment: Body is too long (maximum is 5000 characters)"

Will have to come back to this tonight when I have more time.

Posted by louisb about 1 year ago

[Subgenus Achillides]

Promote Papilio (Achillides) paris ssp. arjuna to Papilio (Achillides) arjuna
Promote Papilio (Achillides) palinurus ssp. daedalus to Papilio (Achillides) daedalus
Check Papilio (Achillides) okinawensis (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)
Add Papilio (Achillides) orsippus
Add Papilio (Achillides) orsippus orsippus
Add Papilio (Achillides) orsippus ambiguus
Add Papilio (Achillides) orsippus kallinikos
Add Papilio (Achillides) orsippus rothschildianus
Add Papilio (Achillides) polyctor
Promote Papilio (Achillides) ulysses ssp. telegonus to Papilio (Achillides) telegonus
Add Papilio (Achillides) telegonus telegonus
Add Papilio (Achillides) telegonus dohertius

[Subgenus Alexanoria]

Add subgenus Papilio (Alexanoria)
Move Papilio (Papilio) alexanor to Papilio (Alexanoria) alexanor

[Subgenus Araminta]

Add subgenus Papilio (Araminta)
Move Papilio (Menelaides) antonio to Papilio (Araminta) antonio
Move Papilio (Menelaides) demolion to Papilio (Araminta) demolion
Move Papilio (Menelaides) gigon to Papilio (Araminta) gigon
Move Papilio (Menelaides) liomedon to Papilio (Araminta) liomedon
Move Papilio (Menelaides) noblei to Papilio (Araminta) noblei

[Subgenus Chilasa]
no changes required

[Subgenus Druryia]

Add subgenus Papilio (Druryia)
Move Papilio (Princeps) andronicus to Papilio (Druryia) andronicus
Move Papilio (Princeps) antimachus to Papilio (Druryia) antimachus
Move Papilio (Princeps) arnoldiana to Papilio (Druryia) arnoldiana
Move Papilio (Princeps) bacelarae to Papilio (Druryia) bacelarae
Move Papilio (Princeps) constantinus to Papilio (Druryia) constantinus
Move Papilio (Princeps) cynorta to Papilio (Druryia) cynorta
Move Papilio (Princeps) cyproeofila to Papilio (Druryia) cyproeofila
Move Papilio (Princeps) dardanus to Papilio (Druryia) dardanus
Move Papilio (Princeps) delalandei to Papilio (Druryia) delalandei
Move Papilio (Princeps) echerioides to Papilio (Druryia) echerioides
Move Papilio (Princeps) fernandus to Papilio (Druryia) fernandus
Move Papilio (Princeps) filaprae to Papilio (Druryia) filaprae
Move Papilio (Princeps) fuelleborni to Papilio (Druryia) fuelleborni
Move Papilio (Princeps) gallienus to Papilio (Druryia) gallienus
Promote Papilio (Princeps) dardanus ssp. humbloti to Papilio (Druryia) humbloti
Move Papilio (Princeps) jacksoni to Papilio (Druryia) jacksoni
Move Papilio (Princeps) leucotaenia to Papilio (Druryia) leucotaenia
Move Papilio (Princeps) lormieri to Papilio (Druryia) lormieri
Move Papilio (Princeps) mangoura to Papilio (Druryia) mangoura
Move Papilio (Princeps) mechowi to Papilio (Druryia) mechowi
Move Papilio (Princeps) mechowianus to Papilio (Druryia) mechowianus
Move Papilio (Princeps) menestheus to Papilio (Druryia) menestheus
Promote Papilio (Princeps) dardanus ssp. meriones to Papilio (Druryia) meriones
Move Papilio (Princeps) nobicea to Papilio (Druryia) nobicea
Move Papilio (Princeps) ophidicephalus to Papilio (Druryia) ophidicephalus
Move Papilio (Princeps) phorcas to Papilio (Druryia) phorcas
Move Papilio (Princeps) plagiatus to Papilio (Druryia) plagiatus
Move Papilio (Princeps) rex to Papilio (Druryia) rex
Move Papilio (Princeps) sjoestedti to Papilio (Druryia) sjoestedti
Move Papilio (Princeps) zenobia to Papilio (Druryia) zenobia

[Subgenus Eleppone]
no changes required

[Subgenus Euchenor]

Add subgenus Papilio (Euchenor)
Move Papilio (Menelaides) euchenor to Papilio (Euchenor) euchenor
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) euchenor ssp. depilis to Papilio (Euchenor) depilis
Add Papilio (Euchenor) depilis depilis
Add Papilio (Euchenor) depilis neohannoveranus

[Subgenus Heraclides]

Demote Heraclides to Papilio (Heraclides) including all descendants
Check Heraclides ponceana (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)

Posted by louisb about 1 year ago

[Subgenus Menelaides]

Promote Papilio (Menelaides) memnon ssp. agenor to Papilio (Menelaides) agenor
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) polytes ssp. alphenor to Papilio (Menelaides) alphenor
Add Papilio (Menelaides) biseriatus
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) fuscus ssp. canopus to Papilio (Menelaides) canopus
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) fuscus ssp. capaneus to Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) nephelus ssp. chaon to Papilio (Menelaides) chaon
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) fuscus ssp. cilix to Papilio (Menelaides) cilix
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) helenus ssp. daksha to Papilio (Menelaides) daksha
Check Papilio (Menelaides) demetrius (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)
Check Papilio (Menelaides) duboisi (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) bridgei ssp. erskinei to Papilio (Menelaides) erskinei
Add Papilio (Menelaides) heringi
Add Papilio (Menelaides) hypsicles
Demote Papilio inopinatus to Papilio (Menelaides) aegeus inopinatus
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) polytes ssp. javanus to Papilio (Menelaides) javanus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) aegeus komos
Check Papilio (Menelaides) lowii (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)
Add Papilio (Menelaides) mangarinus
Demote Papilio (Menelaides) mayo to Papilio (Menelaides) memnon mayo
Promote Papilio (Menelaides) aegeus ssp. oritas to Papilio (Menelaides) oritas
Add Papilio (Menelaides) palawanicus
Check Papilio (Menelaides) phestus (I believe from Condamine et al it is a junior synonym?)
Demote Papilio (Menelaides) polymnestor to Papilio (Menelaides) agenor polymnestor
Demote Papilio (Menelaides) rumanzovia to Papilio (Menelaides) deiphobus (not ssp.)
Move Papilio (Menelaides) polymnestor ssp. parinda to Papilio (Menelaides) agenor parinda
Add Papilio (Menelaides) agenor nicobarensis
Move Papilio (Menelaides) memnon ssp. heronus to Papilio (Menelaides) agenor heronus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) agenor iriomotensis
Move Papilio (Menelaides) memnon ssp. thunbergii to Papilio (Menelaides) agenor thunbergii
Add Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus capaneus
Move (Menelaides) Papilio fuscus ssp. beccarii to Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus beccarii
Add Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus gyrei
Add Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus hasterti
Move Papilio (Menelaides) fuscus ssp. indicatus to Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus indicatus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus relmae
Add Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus rotalita
Add Papilio (Menelaides) capaneus xenophilus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) chaon chaon
Move Papilio (Menelaides) nephelus ssp. annulus to Papilio (Menelaides) chaon annulus
Move Papilio (Menelaides) nephelus ssp. chaonulus to Papilio (Menelaides) chaon chaonulus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) chaon rileyi
Add Papilio (Menelaides) cilix cilix
Add Papilio (Menelaides) cilix lamponius
Add Papilio (Menelaides) daksha daksha
Move Papilio (Menelaides) helenus ssp. mooreanus to Papilio (Menelaides) daksha mooreanus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) javanus javanus
Move Papilio (Menelaides) polytes ssp. theseus to Papilio (Menelaides) javanus theseus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) javanus melanides
Move Papilio (Menelaides) polytes ssp. vigellius to Papilio (Menelaides) javanus vigellius
Move Papilio (Menelaides) polytes ssp. messius to Papilio (Menelaides) javanus messius
Add Papilio (Menelaides) javanus sotira
Move Papilio (Menelaides) polytes ssp. timorensis to Papilio (Menelaides) javanus timorensis
Move Papilio (Menelaides) polytes ssp. alcindor to Papilio (Menelaides) javanus alcindor
Add Papilio (Menelaides) javanus kurokawai
Add Papilio (Menelaides) javanus tucanus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) mangarinus mangarinus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) mangarinus jindanus
Add Papilio (Menelaides) mangarinus tambora
Add Papilio (Menelaides) oritas oritas
Move Papilio (Menelaides) aegeus ssp. websteri to Papilio (Menelaides) oritas websteri
Add Papilio (Menelaides) oritas byronensis
Add Papilio (Menelaides) palawanicus palawanicus
Move Papilio (Menelaides) helenus ssp. enganius to Papilio (Menelaides) palawanicus enganius
Add Papilio (Menelaides) palawanicus sinabangana
Add Papilio (Menelaides) palawanicus boloboca

Posted by louisb about 1 year ago

[Subgenus Nireopapilio]

Add subgenus Papilio (Nireopapilio)
Move Papilio (Princeps) aristophontes to Papilio (Nireopapilio) aristophontes
Move Papilio (Princeps) charopus to Papilio (Nireopapilio) charopus
Move Papilio (Princeps) chitondensis to Papilio (Nireopapilio) chitondensis
Move Papilio (Princeps) chrapkowskii to Papilio (Nireopapilio) chrapkowskii
Move Papilio (Princeps) chrapkowskoides to Papilio (Nireopapilio) chrapkowskoides
Move Papilio (Princeps) desmondi to Papilio (Nireopapilio) desmondi
Move Papilio (Princeps) epiphorbas to Papilio (Nireopapilio) epiphorbas
Move Papilio (Princeps) euphranor to Papilio (Nireopapilio) euphranor
Move Papilio (Princeps) hesperus to Papilio (Nireopapilio) hesperus
Move Papilio (Princeps) hornimani to Papilio (Nireopapilio) hornimani
Move Papilio (Princeps) horribilis to Papilio (Nireopapilio) horribilis
Move Papilio (Princeps) interjectana to Papilio (Nireopapilio) interjectana
Move Papilio (Princeps) mackinnoni to Papilio (Nireopapilio) mackinnoni
Move Papilio (Princeps) manlius to Papilio (Nireopapilio) manlius
Move Papilio (Princeps) microps to Papilio (Nireopapilio) microps
Move Papilio (Princeps) nireus to Papilio (Nireopapilio) nireus
Move Papilio (Princeps) nobilis to Papilio (Nireopapilio) nobilis
Move Papilio (Princeps) oribazus to Papilio (Nireopapilio) oribazus
Move Papilio (Princeps) pelodurus to Papilio (Nireopapilio)or pelodurus
Move Papilio (Princeps) phorbanta to Papilio (Nireopapilio) phorbanta
Move Papilio (Princeps) sosia to Papilio (Nireopapilio) sosia
Move Papilio (Princeps) thuraui to Papilio (Nireopapilio) thuraui
Move Papilio (Princeps) ufipa to Papilio (Nireopapilio) ufipa
Move Papilio (Princeps) zalmoxis to Papilio (Nireopapilio) zalmoxis

[Subgenus Papilio]

Promote Papilio (Papilio) machaon ssp. kahli to Papilio (Papilio) kahli
Promote Papilio (Papilio) machaon ssp. bairdii to Papilio (Papilio) bairdii
Demote Papilio (Papilio) saharae to Papilio (Papilio) machaon saharae
Check Papilio (Papilio) verityi (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)
Add Papilio (Papilio) bairdii bairdii
Move Papilio (Papilio) machaon ssp. oregonia to Papilio (Papilio) bairdii oregonia
Move Papilio (Papilio) machaon ssp. dodi to Papilio (Papilio) bairdii dodi

[Subgenus Princeps]

Check Papilio (Princeps) nerminae (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)
Check Papilio (Princeps) wilsoni (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)

[Subgenus Pterourus]

Check Papilio (Pterourus) cleotas (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)
Check Papilio (Pterourus) coroebus (not listed in Condamine et al - ssp?)
Promote Papilio (Pterourus) menatius ssp. victorinus to Papilio (Pterourus) victorinus
Demote Pterourus birchallii to Papilio (Pterourus) birchallii (currently both taxa exist - oversight at some point I suspect)
Add Papilio (Pterourus) victorinus victorinus
Move Papilio (Pterourus) menatius ssp. morelius to Papilio (Pterourus) victorinus morelius
Move Papilio (Pterourus) menatius ssp. vulneratus to Papilio (Pterourus) victorinus vulneratus

[Subgenus Sinoprinceps]

Add subgenus Papilio (Sinoprinceps)
Move Papilio (Papilio) benguetanus to Papilio (Sinoprinceps) benguetana (note gender!)
Move Papilio (Papilio) xuthus to Papilio (Sinoprinceps) xuthus

Posted by louisb about 1 year ago

There we go. I believe that's all the changes proposed in the paper & any others needed to align the iNat taxonomy with that presented therein. All up >150 to make - anyone game?

Posted by louisb about 1 year ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments