False Foxgloves: how to know the species of Agalinis in Texas

False Foxgloves (Agalinis) produce attractive, purple blossoms in late summer through fall. The distribution of these species are poorly documented, so our observations can help with that. There are several species in Texas that are quite similar yet unique in subtle ways.

Here's a guide that I put together as an attempt to note distinguishing features: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1jQ4yVFHhCZ2Yhy7v_Z3ngp-tZIvOKN3UtCBm0mOBbg4/edit?usp=sharing

Generally speaking, here are some features that must be documented (always take pictures of multiple flowers and multiple stems to capture the variation):

  • length of flowering pedicel (relative to length of calyx)
  • length of leaves relative to pedicels
  • orientation of leaves (clasping stem or perpendicular to stem)
  • length of corolla lobes (all the same, or upper shorter than lower)
  • orientation of upper corolla lobes (reflexed or arching over stamens)
  • size of flower (pay attention if small: 8-13 mm long)
  • length of lobes of calyx (relative to tube of calyx)
  • shape of leaves (threadlike, flat-narrow, flat-broad, divided)
  • leafyness (presence of well developed axillary fascicles "extra leaves")
  • I recommend that folks carry with them a white pillow case to use as a backdrop for photographing the plants (if you're serious about getting a good ID--especially for those rare eastern species where leaf length, shape, and density are critical).

BONAP maps of Agalinis: http://bonap.net/Napa/TaxonMaps/Genus/County/Agalinis (not accurate or up to date)

Posted by pfau_tarleton pfau_tarleton, September 05, 2019 14:36

Comments

Thumb

@kimberlietx, @sambiology, @connlindajo, @eric_keith, @rymcdaniel, @alisonnorthup, @anewman, @bob777, @dan_johnson
Feel free to tag anyone else that you might think is interested in documenting False Foxgloves and contributing to ID tips and tricks.

Posted by pfau_tarleton 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

Great! Perfect timing, too. Have you looked at existing observations to see if the multitude of A. heterophylla could be a different species?
@suz You were right... this is the plant that has been driving me crazy all summer.

Posted by kimberlietx 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

I have seen A. heterophylla flowering in several sites in the last 2 weeks.
I have seen Agalinis densiflora in 5 sites in the last few weeks.

Posted by bob777 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

Looks like iNat currently (as of 2019 Sep 5) has 1,214 observations including 15 species (if they are correct?) in Texas, with 609 listed as A. heterophylla. I will be interested to revisit my own 15 observations.
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations?locale=en&place_id=18&preferred_place_id=1&taxon_id=62403&view=species

Posted by oz4caster 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

@kimberlietx, as of now, I'm still too green to verify any IDs. I'm working through keys and descriptions and labeling pictures for a visual guide. At that point, maybe some more experienced souls can verify the guide's accuracy and improve it as needed.

Here's Shinners & Mahler's key in Flora of North Central Texas:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1fqFG1Glxc6IoQ1jaDYsqed3iJHbwoQiX
(this key is missing A. strictifolia, which does occur in ncTX).

I'll try to post a state-wide key tomorrow.

Posted by pfau_tarleton 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

Let me know if I can help out :)

Posted by kimberlietx 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

Wow! That's even tougher than anemones! I'll keep my eye out and do what I can.

Posted by lovebirder 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

OK, brave souls! Here's the key to species of Texas (as of 1970, at least): https://drive.google.com/open?id=1Cs-54_JpAsEO8j0pd9ysySALh3aJKNCW

Posted by pfau_tarleton 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

Alright. So I've found two species growing in the same square foot of soil behind my house, and it's really cool to compare them side by side. I'm really liking the False Foxgloves. Some are easy to distinguish--and I've been brave enough to "correct" a few observations. However, there are some species that have me stumped. The key to species of TX is missing three species: densiflora (easy), harperi (hard), and navasotensis (hard). Anyone can add comments to the guide that I'm working on: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1jQ4yVFHhCZ2Yhy7v_Z3ngp-tZIvOKN3UtCBm0mOBbg4/edit?usp=sharing
@kimberlietx, help!

Posted by pfau_tarleton 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

@kimberlietx, I'm brave enough to start looking through the A. heterophylla--I know enough to know what is NOT heterophylla. LOTS of misidentifications, but many of them are the short-pedicel, east TX species that I'm having trouble with.

I've looked at all TX observations of the following species, and they now appear to be soundly identified: strictifolia, maritima, homalantha, and tenuifolia.

@eric_keith, interested in helping out with this project?

Posted by pfau_tarleton 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

I can't make a huge commitment because of my work load the rest of the year, but if you get stuck on something, I can help. Also, feel free to use all my images. I have most of the species except A. pulchella, which is now very rare or extirpated in Texas. Should be still in frequently burned longleaf pine habitats. A. harperi is most common on Catahoula outcrops in Texas, also along the edge of seepage bogs in Angelina, Jasper, and Newton Counties. It's still quite rare, however. A. purpurea is way more common.

Posted by eric_keith 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

I looked at all 1,281 records of Agalinis in Texas (whew!) and now I think I know the false foxgloves a little better. Last month, they were just a weed to be overlooked! I've only personally seen two species, but hopefully will see more with time and travel. I found some hidden gems among the unidentified and misidentified. And I hope I haven't misidentified anything myself. I'm still adding pics to the guide, and am still trying to get a grasp of distinguishing features of the more rare eastern species. I recommend that folks carry with them a white pillow case to use as a backdrop for photographing the plants (if you're serious about getting a good ID--especially for those rare eastern species where leaf length, shape, and density are critical).

Posted by pfau_tarleton 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

@troutlily57 @jbe_fleischman_fam You might find the guide to ID of different Agilinis species interesting. Click on links above provided by @pfau_tarleton. We should keep at eye out at SRP, see if we can find for A. auriculata!!

Posted by lpenn 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

@pfau_tarleton Thank you for creating this tool and sharing it! Very helpful😁 👍

Posted by lpenn 4 months ago (Flag)
Thumb

Thank you @pfau_tarleton and you too @lpenn for pointing me here! I have not attempted to confirm Agalinis postings on iNat for this exact reason.

Posted by troutlily57 4 months ago (Flag)

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments

Is this inappropriate, spam, or offensive? Add a Flag