Heads up: Some or all of the identifications affected by this split may have been replaced with identifications of Passeriformes. This happens when we can't automatically assign an identification to one of the output taxa. Review identifications of Emberizidae 56039

Taxonomic Split 24891 (Committed on 2017-09-17)

The eBird/Clements checklist of birds... (Citation)
Added by maxkirsch on September 1, 2017 07:24 PM | Committed by maxkirsch on September 17, 2017
split into

Comments

(It's probably better to split the old Emberizidae than to just remove the New World sparrows and rename the old Emberizidae Old World buntings, since that would leave over 100 unidentified sparrow observations in North America labeled as Old World buntings, and shift the community ID on any observation from before the family split with 1 initial ID of Emberizidae and 2 subsequent IDs of, say, Song Sparrow from Song Sparrow to Passeriformes)

Posted by maxkirsch over 6 years ago

(Also, only sort of related, but this year's Clements update should've moved Red-billed Pied Tanager Lamprospiza melanoleuca and Olive-green Tanager Orthogonys chloricterus to the new family Mitrospingidae along with Mitrospingus, but didn't for some reason - I assume we should wait to move them as well because of that?)

Posted by maxkirsch over 6 years ago

@loarie @kueda there isn't any way to atlas families, is there? (I don't see "create an atlas" as an option in the curation drop-down menu for anything above species.)
Emberizidae sensu stricto and Passerellidae are allopatric (Emberizidae in Africa and Eurasia [and introduced to NZ] and Passerellidae in the Americas, apart from rare vagrants in either direction), so being able to automatically assign IDs in North and South America to Passerellidae and IDs in Africa, Eurasia, and NZ to Emberizidae would prevent the over 100 observations with a community ID of Emberizidae sensu lato (and probably hundreds or even thousands of active identifications of that taxon on other observations) from just switching to Passeriformes.

Posted by maxkirsch over 6 years ago

Add a Comment

Sign In or Sign Up to add comments